30th
Sunday in Ordinary Time
Sir 35:12-14; 16-18
Ps 34: 2-3, 17-18, 19, 23
2 Tim 4:6-8, 16-18
Lk 18:9-14
The New American Bible and the Revised Standard Version
translate the lines from Sirach a bit differently. As we just heard from the NAB, “though not
unduly partial toward the weak, yet he hears the cry of the oppressed” while
the RSV translates the same line “He will not show partiality in the case of
the poor, and he will listen to the prayer of one who is wronged.” While the tax collector was not exactly poor or powerless he
was certainly marginalized because of his perceived cooperation with the Romans
and his ability to take a cut of the taxes for himself. The Pharisee earned his money in more
acceptable ways, at least in the eyes of some.
Both Sirach and the Gospel deal in stereotypes. Stereotypes are statistics in narrative form. When applied to large groups they have a
kernel of truth, which, like the mathematical statistics that are taking over
even the simplest decisions in the practice of medicine, may be invalid in any
particular case. For example, Asian men
have black hair and are shorter than American men. However, one need only look at the photo from
my ordination, in which Ignatius, a 6'3" black-haired Taiwanese Jesuit towers over this 5'11" American, to see that only part of the stereotype
applies.
Being poor, being marginalized, or being oppressed do not
automatically make one just, noble or good. They do not
automatically make one humble nor do they confer particular graces exclusive to
those states. None of them are adequate
rationalizations or excuses for sinful behavior. Think back to the song “Gee, Officer Krupke”
in West Side Story which includes the line “We’re depraved on accounta we’re
deprived.” Perhaps the Jets were depraved
on accounta' they were depraved. Justice.
Humility. Grace. All require cooperation of the
individual regardless of bank account or
social standing.
What would our understanding of the Pharisee and the tax-collector
be if the roles were reversed? Suppose
the Pharisee acknowledged his sinfulness and the tax-collector boasted of his
fundamental righteousness, or, to put it into more contemporary terms, suppose
it was the tax-collector who was afflicted with high self-esteem instead of the
Pharisee. Who would be the good guy
then?
In his commentary on this Gospel Luke Timothy Johnson
includes an important caveat. “The
parable itself is one that invites internalization by every reader because it
speaks to something deep within the heart of every human. The love of God can easily turn into an
idolatrous self-love; the gift can quickly be seized as a possession; what
comes from another can be turned into self-accomplishment. Prayer can be transformed into boasting. Piety is not an unambiguous posture.” The contemplative literature contains many
references to the sin of taking pride in one’s humility. It is a strong temptation. Only a very fine
line separates humility and exaggerated self-esteem.
In reality we all pray in the manner of the Pharisee at
times. Even the humble tax-collector
probably lapsed into the same kind of critical
“there-but-for-the-grace-of-God-go-I” prayer as the Pharisee. If nothing else the daily examen should keep
us realistically humble.
Paul’s words in the letter to Timothy are significant in that
they illustrate that we are all, rich and poor, oppressed and powerful, and in any social stratum, capable of dishonorable behavior. “At my first defense, no one appeared on my
behalf, but everyone deserted me.”
Everyone. Not those with the most
to lose but everyone. And then he goes
on.
“But the Lord stood by me and gave me strength.”
Our only hope is in the Lord. Our only life raft is prayer.
Last Sunday we heard Ps 121:
"I lift up my eyes toward the
mountains;
whence shall help come to me?
My help is from the Lord,
who made heaven and earth.
whence shall help come to me?
My help is from the Lord,
who made heaven and earth.
My help is from the Lord,
who made heaven and earth."
who made heaven and earth."
Today, in Ps 34, we hear:
"The Lord is close to the
brokenhearted;
and those who are crushed in spirit he saves.
The Lord redeems the lives of his servants;
no one incurs guilt who takes refuge in him."
and those who are crushed in spirit he saves.
The Lord redeems the lives of his servants;
no one incurs guilt who takes refuge in him."
St. Ignatius understood human
nature well. Had he lived a few
centuries later he would have been a tremendous psychiatrist. He was aware that all of us are capable of opting for the good and the holy. Poverty and disadvantage are no more get out
of jail free cards than riches and comfort are go directly to jail do not pass
go orders. All of us are sinners. All of us are called to prayer. All of us are called to holiness. Rich or poor.
Pharisee or tax-collector.
Democrat or Republican. No one is saved or damned because of his
financial status, political affiliation or any other characteristic save that of being human.
"The Lord redeems the lives
of his servants;
no one incurs guilt who takes
refuge in him.
Stay with that thought for the
rest of the day."
_______________________________________________________________
This autumn has been a tremendous one. Most of the guys in the house agree that the leaves have been more vibrant than they've been in the past several years. ONe of the great gifts of being back in the North where I belong as opposed to the wrong side of the Mason-Dixon Line, is the aromas of autumn here in New England. There was some rain overnight. The outdoor temp was around forty (it was twenty-eight yesterday morning). The indescribable aroma of autumn made me want to stay outdoors all day. But, because I have to finish a lecture I am giving in Florida in a week, that is not possible.
Al, one of my roommates at Penn State, and his wife Karen, came to visit. We've known each other for 45 years. They wanted to visit nearby Walden Pond. Great place to visit on a Wednesday afternoon. I wouldn't even think about taking someone there on a lovely Saturday afternoon in the fall. The leaves were about two days from absolute peak.
Had to make an unanticipated trip to the retreat house in Gloucester, MA two days ago. Of course I took the camera. This is the delivery road. Niles Pond is just to the right of the brush with the Atlantic just behind where I was standing to take the photo.
A week later Jerry who I've known for 63 years and his wife Ruth came up. Only because they were here did I go on the Boston Harbor Cruise to the Charlestown Navy Yard, a delightful 45 minute trip around the harbor. The other cruise options were already closed for the season. Plans for next spring will include one or two of the tours. The first is the American Flag taken through the T sign. The other is a portion of the Boston skyline.
+Fr. Jack, SJ, MD